Integrative Medicine for CYSHCN
- Other Names & Coding
- Key Points
- Practice Guidelines
- Speaking with Families about Integrative Medicine
- Types of Integrative Medicine
- Medical Systems
- Mind-Body Therapies
- Natural Medicine/Natural Products/Dietary Supplements
- Finding Evidence-Based Recommendations
- Referrals & Services
- CPT & ICD-10 Codes
- Resources
Integrative medicine includes practices that are complementary to allopathic medicine. In 2011, about 1:9 children and more than 50% of children with chronic illnesses used complementary therapies. [McClafferty: 2017] [McClafferty: 2019] In children, taking non-vitamin, non-mineral natural supplements is the most common complementary practice. [Levy: 2015] The prevalence of non-allopathic approaches demonstrates the importance of providing information to families who seek an integrative approach.
Key Points
Collaboration
Consider collaborating with integrative medicine specialists to
help patients struggling with pain, anxiety, depression, headaches, digestive
disorders like constipation, menstrual problems, chronic fatigue, and arthritis.
Recognize that these providers usually treat the whole person and do not focus
on just "the headache" or "the pain." While some modalities have eclectic
certification programs, primary care providers should try to steer families
toward trained and certified integrative medicine practitioners.
Ask about alternative medicine use
Primary care clinicians
should ask specifically about the use of supplements and other complementary or
alternative medicine practices. They can provide guidance on the potential for
drug interactions, known side effects, potential exposure to toxins, or
overdose. They can also provide a perspective on cost vs. benefit, point
families toward evidence-based approaches that are considered safe and
effective, and give referrals to practitioners who are licensed and boarded.
Avoid having the child’s neck manipulated
For families who choose to obtain chiropractic or osteopathic
manipulation for their child, advise them to avoid having the child's neck
manipulated aggressively. Take special precautions with patients with an
increased risk of vascular dissection, instability issues (like atlanto-axial
instability that can occur with Down syndrome), and hypermobility concerns (that
can occur with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome).
Acupuncture vs. needling
Not all acupuncture is the same. A licensed acupuncturist's
training is nearly 3,000 hours, whereas physical therapists who perform needling
often get 40-200 hours of training. Dry needling (with or without electrical
stimulation) done by physical therapists is controversial and illegal in
multiple states. Advise precaution if having needles placed around the pleural
cavity as pneumothoraces can occur.
Herbalists' training varies greatly
The American Herbalists Guild
recommends a program of at least 1600 hours of study at a school of herbal
medicine, including a 400-hour clinical requirement to become a practicing
herbalist. Practitioners who have a Doctorate in Naturopathic Medicine or
Masters in Oriental Medicine have fulfilled this requirement of study. A
licensed acupuncturist and a licensed chiropractor will not have the same level
of training.
Essential oils could have deleterious effects on children’s bodies
Although high-quality research is lacking, several case studies
link lavender and tea tree oil to prepubertal gynecomastia in boys and possible
premature thelarche in girls; these have been dubbed potential "endocrine
disruptors." Encourage families interested in using essential oils to work with
a certified professional. The National Association for Holistic Aromatherapy (NAHA), an organization promoting standards
for certification in aromatherapy, offers a database of providers.
When to avoid using integrative medicine
Similar to how providers evaluate each conventional treatment's
risks and benefits, the same should be done for integrative medicine. Consider
whether the treatment being pursued would delay a treatment that would be
curative or urgent. [McClafferty: 2019]
Practice Guidelines
-
McClafferty H, Vohra S, Bailey M, Brown M, Esparham A, Gerstbacher D, Golianu B, Niemi AK, Sibinga E, Weydert J, Yeh AM.
Pediatric Integrative Medicine.
Pediatrics. 2017;140(3). PubMed abstract
Speaking with Families about Integrative Medicine
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health offers the acronym ARMED (Ask, Respect, Monitor, Educate, and Distribute) to help clinicians talk with families about integrative and complementary health practices.
Other recommended practices:
- Ensure families have access to standard services and are actively involved in all treatment decisions.
- Attempt to determine an etiologic of the child’s condition. Explain current biologic understanding of the child's condition.
- Discuss controversial and complementary therapies as part of the initial management plan and whenever asked.
- Be knowledgeable about standard and nonstandard treatments, or refer for consultation. Since it is difficult to keep current on all the alternative therapies, the primary care clinician may ask the family to schedule a follow-up appointment to allow the provider time for a literature review and discuss the proposed therapy in depth.
- Schedule ample time for the discussion, making certain your comments are not taken as an endorsement. Discuss the placebo effect and the importance of controlled research trials. Be ready to explain the difference between a case report and a controlled trial.
- Provide information about the specific treatment, discuss decision-making, and emphasize the red flags, such as the claim of an unrealistic cure or that every child will benefit.
- Identify any confounding factors, e.g., opinions of relatives.
- Be willing to support a trial of therapy in select situations; require clear treatment objectives and pre/post evaluation of symptoms.
- Remain actively involved even if you do not agree with the parent's decision. If you can't do this and maintain an open therapeutic relationship, consider a referral to a medical home where the parents and the provider may more closely share the same philosophy.
- If you feel that the alternative therapy and/or the declining of traditional therapeutic approaches for the alternative therapy is too risky, suggest that the family establish a new medical home that feels more comfortable with the family's choice.
Further details about how to speak with families about integrative medicine can be found at [McClafferty: 2017] and [Nickel: 2003].
Types of Integrative Medicine
In the United States, many people consider allopathic or Western medicine (e.g., performed by a medical doctor, osteopathic doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician’s assistant) to be “mainstream” or “conventional.” However, this framework depends on what system the family is most familiar with; a newly immigrated family may not consider Western medical practices to be “conventional.” Practices that can be combined with Western or allopathic medicine are considered complementary; those practices used instead of allopathic medicine are often considered “alternative.” Integrative health brings together mainstream and complementary practices for a holistic approach to health. This section briefly summarizes some well-known complementary practices. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NIH) is a good source of information for clinicians and families.
Medical Systems
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) / Oriental Medicine (OM)
Ayurveda Medicine
Homeopathy
Naturopathy
Functional Medicine
Mind-Body Therapies
Acupuncture and Acupressure
Biofeedback
Hypnotherapy/Hypnosis
Osteopathy
Chiropractic
Massage Therapy
Meditation
Mindfulness
Relaxation Techniques
Yoga
Tai Chi
Natural Medicine/Natural Products/Dietary Supplements
Aroma Therapy & Essential Oils
Herbal Medicine or Phytotherapy
- National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NIH) Herbs at a Glance (Herb List App) to evaluate the evidence for and safety of individual herbal products
- American Herbalists Guild for information on professional training
- Drugs, Herbs, & Supplements (MedlinePlus)) for an herb list and natural medicine database
- Natural Medicines Database (TRC Healthcare) database to identify the side effects and benefits of natural products (requires a subscription)
Vitamins & Minerals
Prebiotics
Probiotics
Nasal Saline Irrigation
Honey
Melatonin
Finding Evidence-Based Recommendations
The National Institute of Health developed the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NIH), which has clinical guidelines, information on use and side effects of various herbs, continuing medical education opportunities to learn more about integrative medicine, clinical trials, and grant opportunities. It also provides an overview of the current evidence behind the use of the most common natural products, including melatonin, omega-3 fatty acids (fish oil), probiotics, cranberry, echinacea, garlic supplements, and ginseng (see ).
The Office of Dietary Supplements provides clinical resources about dietary supplements and offers a free app, Herb List App, to provide rapid access information about herbal supplements – this can be shared with families so they can look up the latest evidence and safety concerns while they are shopping.
Many of the professional organizations listed with the specific types of practice (above) provide more information on research and evidence for use of their modality.
CPT & ICD-10 Codes
Appropriately trained primary care clinicians may provide these services; however, they should be associated with diagnosis codes for covered services.
Procedure | CPT Codes (if a physician performs the service) |
Acupuncture | 9781x |
Biofeedback training, any modality | 90901 |
Hypnotherapy | 90880 |
Osteopathic manipulation | 98925-9 |
Chiropractic manipulation | 98940-3 |
Diagnosis (in ICD-10-CM) | Diagnosis Codes |
Other specified counseling (such as for health advice or counseling) | Z71.89 |
Resources
Information & Support
Related Portal Content
For Professionals
National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NIH)
A wealth of information, research, and training for patients and clinicians on the use and safety of complementary and alternative
medicines; National Institutes of Health.
Natural Medicines Database (TRC Healthcare)
Safety, effectiveness, and interactions of many dietary supplements, herbal medicines, and integrative therapies. Continuing
Education courses offered; requires a subscription.
American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP)
A national professional society that helps build successful medical practices, has a searchable provider database, and expands
the body of naturopathic medicine research.
Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM)
Education, training, licensed provider database, and research related to functional medicine.
Association for Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback (AAPB)
Lists the results of formal studies about the efficacy of AAPB when used with specific disorders, outlines recommended treatment,
and hosts a searchable database of biofeedback practitioners.
National Association for Holistic Aromatherapy (NAHA)
Scientific, empirical, and current information about aromatherapy and essential oils. Promotes practice standards for the
profession and has a searchable database of aromatherapists.
Pediatric Acupuncture Evidence Summary
Scrutinizes the evidence base of different studies using acupuncture to treat several different common pediatric conditions
(e.g., cerebral palsy, asthma, chronic pain).
National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM)
Promotes national evidence-based standards of competence and credentialing and maintains a searchable database of board-certified,
licensed acupuncture and oriental medicine providers.
American Society of Clinical Hypnosis (ASCH) Member Referral Service
A searchable database of hypnotists with degrees in many disciplines, including medicine, podiatry, dentistry, osteopathy,
psychology, social work, counseling, marriage and family therapy, and nursing.
For Parents and Patients
Children and the Use of Complementary Health Approaches (NCCIH)
Science, side effects, and the bottom line when considering complementary health approaches; National Center for Complementary
and Integrative Health.
Drugs, Herbs, & Supplements (MedlinePlus)
Information for families that includes description, frequency, causes, inheritance, other names, and additional resources;
from the National Library of Medicine.
American Holistic Health Association (AHHA)
Integrative health and wellness resources (both conventional and complementary) to cope with an illness or to enhance health.
Includes a database for holistic provider referrals.
Patient Education
Let's Talk About... Aromatherapy with Essential Oils (Spanish & English)
Printable handout on the use and safety of aromatherapy to treat children; Intermountain Healthcare.
Let's Talk About... Traditional Chinese Medicine (Spanish & English)
Printable information briefly explaining traditional Chinese medicine and its various forms; Intermountain Healthcare.
Let's Talk About... Acupuncture (Spanish & English)
Printable handout explaining the use and safety of acupuncture in children; Intermountain Healthcare.
Let's Talk About... Massage Therapy: Before, During, and After (Spanish & English)
Printable handout about how to prepare your child for what to expect before, during, and after a massage; Intermountain Healthcare.
Let's Talk About... Essential Oils and Deep Breathing (Spanish & English)
Printable information about using essential oils with deep or focused breathing to help children relax and heal; Intermountain
Healthcare.
Let's Talk About... Breathing Techniques (Spanish & English)
Printable information about different breathing techniques that children and adolescents can use to relax; Intermountain Healthcare.
Tools
My Medicine Record (U.S. Food & Drug)
Fillable form to keep track of all of prescriptions, over-the-counter medications, supplements, medical conditions, past surgeries,
allergies, physician contact information, and preferred pharmacy.
Services for Patients & Families in New Mexico (NM)
Service Categories | # of providers* in: | NM | NW | Other states (3) (show) | | NV | RI | UT |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pediatric Integrative Medicine | 1 |
For services not listed above, browse our Services categories or search our database.
* number of provider listings may vary by how states categorize services, whether providers are listed by organization or individual, how services are organized in the state, and other factors; Nationwide (NW) providers are generally limited to web-based services, provider locator services, and organizations that serve children from across the nation.
Studies
Studies of Integrative Health in Children and Adolescents (clinicaltrial.gov)
Studies looking at better understanding, diagnosing, and treating this condition; from the National Library of Medicine.
Authors & Reviewers
Author: | Hannah Hrobuchak, MD |
Senior Author: | Jennifer Goldman, MD, MRP, FAAP |
2019: update: Jennifer Goldman, MD, MRP, FAAPA; Karena Luttmer, DACM, MSOM, L.AcR; Michael Green, DOR |
2013: first version: Lisa Samson-Fang, MDA; Lynne M. Kerr, MD, PhDA |
Page Bibliography
Dan W. Thomas, MD, Frank R. Greer, MD.
Probiotics and Prebiotics in Pediatrics.
Pediatrics.
2010;126(6).
/ Full Text
This clinical report reviews the currently known health benefits of probiotic and prebiotic products, including those added
to commercially available infant formula and other food products for use in children.
Dobson D, Lucassen PL, Miller JJ, Vlieger AM, Prescott P, Lewith G.
Manipulative therapies for infantile colic.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2012;12:CD004796.
PubMed abstract
A systematic review of 6 studies that arrived at no definitive conclusion about the effectiveness of manipulative therapies
for infantile colic, although the majority of the included trials appeared to indicate that the parents of infants receiving
manipulative therapies reported (statistically significant) fewer hours crying per day than parents whose infants did not.
Driehuis F, Hoogeboom TJ, Nijhuis-van der Sanden MWG, de Bie RA, Staal JB.
Spinal manual therapy in infants, children and adolescents: A systematic review and meta-analysis on treatment indication,
technique and outcomes.
PLoS One.
2019;14(6):e0218940.
PubMed abstract / Full Text
A systematic review that found little quality evidence to guide conclusions about the effectiveness of spinal manipulation
in treating pediatric patients. The authors stated that "gentle, low-velocity spinal mobilizations seem to be a safe treatment
technique in infants, children and adolescents."
Goldenberg JZ, Lytvyn L, Steurich J, Parkin P, Mahant S, Johnston BC.
Probiotics for the prevention of pediatric antibiotic-associated diarrhea.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2015(12):CD004827.
PubMed abstract
Moderate quality evidence suggests a protective effect of a few types of probiotics in preventing AAD.
Holm LV, Jarbøl DE, Christensen HW, Søndergaard J, Hestbæk L.
The effect of chiropractic care on infantile colic: results from a single-blind randomised controlled trial.
Chiropr Man Therap.
2021;29(1):15.
PubMed abstract / Full Text
Jonas WB, Kaptchuk TJ, Linde K.
A critical overview of homeopathy.
Ann Intern Med.
2003;138(5):393-9.
PubMed abstract
Levy SE, Hyman SL.
Complementary and alternative medicine treatments for children with autism spectrum disorders.
Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am.
2015;24(1):117-43.
PubMed abstract
This review discusses factors associated with use of CAM for children with autism spectrum disorder, the empirical evidence
for the most frequently used treatments, and how clinicians work with families who choose CAM treatments.
Mathis ET, Dente E, Biel MG.
Applying Mindfulness-Based Practices in Child Psychiatry.
Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am.
2019;28(2):209-220.
PubMed abstract
McClafferty H.
An Overview of Pediatric Integrative Medicine.
Pediatr Ann.
2019;48(6):e216-e219.
PubMed abstract
McClafferty H, Vohra S, Bailey M, Brown M, Esparham A, Gerstbacher D, Golianu B, Niemi AK, Sibinga E, Weydert J, Yeh AM.
Pediatric Integrative Medicine.
Pediatrics.
2017;140(3).
PubMed abstract
Reviews common types of complementary therapies, the education required for practitioners, and communication strategies for
discussing integrative medicine with families.
Nickel RE, Desch LW.
The Physician's Guide to Caring for Children with Disabilities and Chronic Conditions.
Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co;
2003.
Ong TG, Gordon M, Banks SS, Thomas MR, Akobeng AK.
Probiotics to prevent infantile colic.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2019;3:CD012473.
PubMed abstract / Full Text
There is no clear evidence that probiotics are more effective than placebo at preventing infantile colic; however, daily crying
time appeared to reduce with probiotic use compared to placebo.
Parry SM, Staenberg B, Weaver MS.
Mindful Movement: Tai Chi, Gentle Yoga, and Qi Gong for Hospitalized Pediatric Palliative Care Patients and Family Members.
J Palliat Med.
2018;21(9):1212-1213.
PubMed abstract
An exploratory study of using music and mindful movement to improve overall well-being of inpatient pediatric palliative patients
and their family caregivers.